Comprehensive rail plan could boost Caltrain - BART to remain backbone, but commuter train will be key spur (by Will,
Daily News)
A $45 million plan to improve and integrate the Bay Area's myriad rail lines would affect the Peninsula mainly by expanding and upgrading Caltrain, transportation officials said Monday. About 100 people crammed into an auditorium in San Carlos Monday for a public workshop on the Bay Area Regional Rail Plan, which was released earlier this month and could be approved by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission next month.
While the plan envisions BART as the "backbone" of the region's transit system, it calls for Caltrain to remain the key spur connecting San Jose to San Francisco. Accordingly, it calls for Caltrain to go electric, build tunnels at major crossings, expand across the Dumbarton Bridge, and possibly add tracks to accommodate high-speed trains running from Los Angeles to San Francisco. Regionally, it calls for BART to link up with Caltrain in San Jose and to add a second transbay tube from San Francisco to Oakland.
The result, proponents say, would be a seamless ring of trains around the Bay, relieving clogged highways and reducing air pollution. While none of the ideas are brand-new, their inclusion in the rail plan gives them a regional backing that could help them become a reality. The obstacle, of course, is money.
The local officials and residents who spoke at Monday's workshop had mixed reviews of the plan. Many praised the basic concept but criticized certain aspects, such as the short amount of time available for public input and the lack of detail in the ridership and cost projections. Several focused on the plan's connection to a separate, statewide high-speed rail program aimed at zipping passengers between Southern California and the Bay Area in under three hours. That proposal adds uncertainty to the MTC's regional plan, because its advocates are still deciding between at least two route plans.
One would send trains through the Pacheco Pass and up through San Jose to San Francisco. The other has them going through the Altamont Pass and through the East Bay before splitting. The MTC's plan includes both options, and the commission has yet to decide whether to endorse one or the other.
Caltrain Chief Development Official Ian McAvoy on Monday gave an enthusiastic thumbs-up to the regional rail plan, saying that although the costs are high, the rewards would be higher. He also backed the high-speed rail program, saying Caltrain would welcome the express trains on its tracks. Doug Kimsey, planning director for the MTC, noted that the high-speed rail plan could bring a windfall of state money for Caltrain. That's because it would require the trains to be electrified and the tracks widened and separated from road crossings by over- and underpasses, which Caltrain wants to do anyway.
But some local residents fear that trains running up to 200 miles per hour through their towns would be disruptive. "I'm worried about how much more they're going to divide our towns," said Bobbi Benson of Burlingame. Her sentiment was echoed by Atherton Vice Mayor James Janz, who wondered how much Peninsula residents would benefit from the high-speed line. Burlingame Council Member Rosalie O'Mahoney wondered about the expense of the proposed grade separations at crossings, noting that they can cost $100 million each.
Dan Cruey, president of the San Mateo County Economic Development Association, argued the improvements and the high-speed rail are essential for the region's economic growth. He praised the MTC's plan for regional transit integration, saying, "We've got a number of transit systems in the Bay Area that don't currently work together."
The San Carlos workshop was the last of five around the Bay Area. The MTC will take comments under consideration and aims to approve a final regional rail plan by the end of September.
Additional article in
Examiner
- Written by Fiona
Recent Comments